Constructing a ‘building code’ for medical device software security

The following summary of the recent ‘building code’ workshop sponsored in part by THaW held on November 19-21, 2014 is provided by Dr. Carl Landwehr —

Forty people with diverse backgrounds in medical device software development, standards, regulation, security, and software engineering met in New Orleans November 19-21 with the goal of constructing a “building code” for medical device software security and a related research agenda. The workshop was sponsored by National Science Foundation through both the Trustworthy Health and Wellness (THaW) center and a separate workshop grant to George Washington University’s Cyber Security Policy and Research Institute (CSPRI) as well as the IEEE Computer Society’s Cybersecurity initiative.

The idea of exploiting building code metaphor originated with THaW’s Carl Landwehr, who organized the meeting with the help of a Steering Group that included THaW leadership as well as several others from the worlds of medical devices, software engineering, and security. Tom Haigh, recently retired from Adventium, served as Vice-Chair.

Building codes for physical structures grow out of industry and professional society groups – suppliers, builders and architects – rather than from government, although adoption of codes by government provides the legal basis for enforcement.  Building codes generally apply to designs, building processes, and the finished product. Code enforcement relies on inspections of structures during construction and of the finished product and also on certification of the skills of the participants in the design, construction, and inspection processes. Inspectors must be knowledgeable and skilled, but the training requirement is not burdensome, and decisions as to whether a building meets the code or not are typically straightforward. Codes also take account of different domains of use of structures: code requirements for single-family dwellings differ from those for public buildings, for example. Although building codes arose largely from safety considerations (e.g. reducing the risk of widespread damage to cities from fires, hurricanes, or earthquakes), security from malicious attack has also motivated some aspects of building codes.

The workshop aimed to develop an analog to building codes focused on the security properties of software rather than the structure and characteristics of physical building.  The objective of this code for software security is to increase assurance that software developed for the domain of medical devices will be free of many of the security vulnerabilities that plague software generally.  Evidence to date is that a large fraction of exploitable security flaws are not design flaws but rather implementation flaws. An initial building code for medical device software security could focus on assuring that the final software that operates the device is free of these kinds of flaws, although it could address aspects of the development process as well.  For example, the code might specify that modules written in a language that permits buffer overflows be subject to particular inspection or testing requirements, while modules written in type-safe languages might require a lesser degree of testing but a stronger inspection of components that translate the source language to executable form.

About 35 separate items were proposed for inclusion in an initial draft building code. Although the final report is still in development, only about half of these elements are likely to be included in the consensus version of the code.

Several participants in the workshop who are active in related standards bodies and professional societies have indicated an interest in moving the code forward in those groups.

One thought on “Constructing a ‘building code’ for medical device software security

  1. Pingback: A ‘building code’ for building secure code in medical devices | Trustworthy Health and Wellness

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s